For the three people out there (including my pal Chris, of course) who still care - the final tallies for the 5151 Marvel characters who received a vote!
Enjoy!
Spider-Man - 2164 (103)
Captain America - 1616 (43)
Daredevil (Matt Murdock) - 1006 (22)
Dr. Doom - 872 (15)
The Thing (Ben Grimm) - 850 (12)
Hulk - 730 (15 points for Joe Fixit, 9 for "Professor Hulk") (13)
Wolverine - 728 (10)
Hawkeye - 662 (17)
Thor - 605 (12)
Cyclops - 604 (13)
Iron Man (Tony Stark) - 603 (11)
Nightcrawler - 497 (12)
Magneto - 465 (7)
Dr. Strange - 464 (12)
Silver Surfer - 461 (8)
Beast - 456 (8)
Deadpool - 443 (13)
Shadowcat (Kitty Pryde) - 427 (9)
Jamie Madrox, The Multiple Man- 399 (11)
Jean Grey (Marvel Girl/Phoenix) - 374 (13)
Punisher - 267 (7)
Emma Frost (White Queen) - 309 (1)
Iron Fist - 325
Thanos - 287 (5)
She-Hulk - 283 (9)
Ultimate Spider-Man - 261 (12)
Sub-Mariner (Namor McKenzie) - 222 (2)
Nova - 222 (6)
Nick Fury - 221 (2)
Storm - 209 (3)
31. Colossus - 208 (2)
32. Galactus - 191 (4)
33. Power Man (Luke Cage) - 190 (1)
34. Adam Warlock - 186 (3)
35. Ms. Marvel - 185
36. Rogue - 183 (2)
37. Invisible Woman (Sue Storm/Richards) - 170 (1)
38. Princess Powerful/Bruiser (Molly Hayes) - 167 (1)
39. Human Torch (Johnny Storm) - 163
40. Ultimate Captain America - 161 (1)
41. Gambit - 147 (5)
42. The Vision - 146
43. Mary Jane Watson - 144
44. Black Panther - 137 (4)
45. Jessica Jones - 134 (3)
46. Iceman - 132 (5)
47. Howard the Duck - 131 (1)
48. J. Jonah Jameson - 130 (2)
49 (tie). Mr. Fantastic (Reed Richards) - 128
49 (tie). Bucky/Winter Soldier (James Buchanan Barnes) - 128
Captain Marvel (Mar-Vell) - 126 (1)
Green Goblin (Norman Osborn) - 125
The Angel (Warren Worthington III) - 125
Moon Knight - 125
Scarlet Witch - 124
Beta Ray Bill - 122
Hank Pym (29 as Pym, 4 as Gol., 21 as A-M, 38 as YJ, 29 as GM) - 121
Quasar (Wendell Vaughn) - 120 (6)
Squirrel Girl - 119 (3)
Cable - 110 (2)
Ghost Rider (Johnny Blaze) - 104 (1)
Venom - 104 (2)
Robbie Baldwin (Speedb - 73 (1), Pen. 21 (1), Robbie Baldwin 9) 103 (1)
Bullseye - 101
Ultimate Thor - 99 (1)
Spider-Woman (Jessica Drew) - 94 (4)
Wiccan - 93 (1)
Wonder Man - 91
Havok - 89 (2)
Wasp - 86
Psylocke - 86 (1)
Cannonball - 82 (2)
Professor X (Charles Xavier) - 80 (2)
Longshot - 80 (3)
Magik (Illyana Rasputin) - 77 (2)
MODOK - 76 (2)
Jubilee - 74 (3)
Captain Britain - 72 (1)
Taskmaster - 72
Hulkling - 70
Machine Man (Aaron Stack) - 69 (1)
Rick Jones - 69 (1)
Quicksilver - 68
Mr. Sinister - 67
Black Knight (Dane Whitman) - 64
Northstar - 63 (1)
Kingpin - 63
Black Widow (Natalia Romanova/Natasha Romanoff) - 62
Hercules - 62 (1)
Red Skull - 62
Dr. Octopus - 61
Black Bolt - 61 (1)
Doop - 60 (2)
Rachel Grey/Summers - 60 (1)
Sentry - 60 (2)
Elektra (1 for Skrull Elektra) - 58
Firestar - 57
Mystique - 56 (1)
Kang the Conquerer - 56 (1)
Layla Miller - 56
101. Sister Grimm (Nico Minoru) - 55
102. Irredeemable Ant-Man - 54
103. Apocalypse - 53
104. Black Cat - 52
Ben Reilly - 52 (1)
106. Cloak and Dagger - 51
Talkback (Chase Stein) - 51 (1)
108. Monica Rambeau - 50
The Falcon - 50
110. Dazzler - 49
111. Dani Moonstar - 48
Loki - 48
113. Chamber - 47
Banshee - 47 (2)
Justice - 47 (2)
116. Blink - 46
Captain Marvel (Genis-Vell) - 46
Arsenic (Gertrude Yolkes) - 46
Shang-Chi - 46
120. Polaris - 45 (1)
121. Harry Osborn - 44
122. Spider-Man 2099 - 42 (2)
123. Ultimate Nick Fury - 41
124. Juggernaut - 39
Mr. Sensitive/The Orphan (Guy Smith) - 39 (1)
126. Morph - 38 (1)
Marvel Boy (Noh-Varr) - 38
128. Baron Zemo - 37
Blade - 37 (2)
Warlock - 37 (1)
131. Wolfsbane - 36 (1)
Aunt May - 36
133. Valkyrie - 35 (1)
Ultimate Iron Man - 35 (1)
Bishop - 35 (1)
136. M - 34
Man-Thing - 34
The Human Torch (Jim Hammond) - 34
139. The Captain (Nextwave) - 33
Moondragon - 33
141. The Shocker - 32
142. Ultimate Hawkeye - 31
143. Awesome Andy - 29 (1)
Sasquatch - 29
U-Go Girl - 29 (1)
146. Union Jack (Joey Chapman) - 28
Strong Guy - 28
148. Ultimate Hulk - 27 (1)
Drax the Destroyer - 27
Arachne / Spider-Woman (Julia Carpenter) - 27
Songbird - 27
Ka-Zar - 27
The Watcher - 27
Spider-Girl - 27
155. Rocket Raccoon - 26
Killraven - 26 (1)
Ultron - 26
158. Lockheed - 25
Ant-Man (Scott Lang) - 25
Flatman - 25 (1)
161. Stingray - 24
Cypher - 24
Rhino - 24
164. Sandman - 23
Warriors Three (4 for Hogun, 2 for Volstagg) - 23
Gravity - 23
War Machine - 23
168. Fin Fang Foom - 22
Quasar (Phylla-Vell) - 22
Pete Wisdom - 22
Dirk Anger - 22
The Shroud - 22
173. Siryn - 21
The Hood - 21
Mr. Immortal - 21
Ares - 21
Foggy Nelson - 21
Medusa - 21
Namorita - 21 (1)
Red Ghost and his Super-Apes - 21 (1)
181. Hyperion (Squadron Supreme) - 20
Union Jack (James Montgomery) - 20 (1)
Tigra - 20 (1)
184. Stilt-Man - 19
Xorn - 19
Morbius - 19 (1)
Sabretooth - 19
The Enchantress (Amora) - 19
189. Cloud 9 - 18
Cecilia Reyes - 18
Ghost Rider (Dan Ketch) - 18
Son of Satan - 18
Hellion - 18
194. Hellcat (Patsy Walker) - 17 (1)
Maggott - 17
Sunfire (Shiro Yoshida) - 17 (1)
Fabulous Frog-Man - 17 (1)
Nomad - 17
Guardian - 17
Franklin Richards - 17
Echo - 17
202. Thunderstrike - 16 (1)
Impossible Man - 16
Amadeus Cho - 16 (1)
Vindicator (Heather Hudson) - 16
Super Skrull - 16
Carnage - 16
Dormammu - 16
Ultimate Colossus - 16
X-23 - 16 (1)
Hyperion (Supreme Power) - 16 (1)
Johnny Blaze - 16
X-Man (Nate Grey) - 16
Gladiator - 16
215. Amanda Sefton - 15
Star-Lord - 15
Crossbones - 15
Shanna the She-Devil - 15 (1)
Slapstick - 15
Black Queen (Selene) - 15 (1)
The Zombie (Simon Garth) - 15
Darkhawk - 15 (1)
223. Joe "Robbie" Robertson - 14
Ultimate Kitty Pryde - 14
Karma - 14
226. Jack of Hearts - 13
Power Pack - 13
Meggan - 13
Diamondback - 13
Maddie Pryor - 13
Man-Wolf - 13
Hobgoblin - 13
Sleepwalker - 13
Agent-X - 13
Dark Beast - 13 (1)
236. Omega Red - 12
Old Lace - 12
Ben Urich - 12
Hannibal King - 12
Abomination - 12
Forge - 12
USAgent - 12
243. Ghost/Phantom Rider - 11
Iron Lad - 11 (1)
Two-Gun Kid - 11
Dracula - 11
Death's Head - 11
248. Pyro - 10 (1)
Bernard the Poet - 10 (1)
Spider-Ham - 10
Debrii - 10 (1)
Green Goblin (Phil Urich) - 10 (1)
The Blob - 10 (1)
Lockjaw - 10
Anaconda - 10 (1)
Victor Mancha (Runaways) - 10
Cassandra Nova - 10
Vance Astro - 10
Beak - 10
Marrow - 10 (1)
261. Human Fly - 9
Rictor (Julio Rictor) - 9
Ruby Thursday - 9
D'Spayre - 9
The Wrecker - 9
Electro - 9
Giganto - 9
The Constrictor - 9
Frenzy/Cargill - 9
Firelord - 9
Mephisto - 9
Odin - 9
Skin - 9
Shalla Bal - 9
Fantomex - 9
DP7 (New Universe) - 9
Titania - 9
Dead Girl - 9
Spitfire(Jacqueline Montgomery) - 9
Black Panther (Kasper Cole) - 9
Nighthawk - 9
282. Giganto II - 8
Kaluu - 8
Sabra - 8
The Darkhold Redeemers - 8
Aurora - 8
Scorpion (Mac Gargan) - 8
Nocturne (Exiles) - 8
Stature - 8
Blizzard (Donnie Gill) - 8
Dr. Bong - 8
Juston Seyfert - 8
Ultimate Mary Jane Watson - 8
Agatha Harkness - 8
Domino - 8
Gwen Stacey - 8
Damage Control - 8
Puck - 8
The Celestials - 8
Mondo - 8
Brother Voodoo - 8
Grim Reaper - 8
Strikeforce Morituri - 8
The Brood - 8
305. Silhouette - 7
Ultimate Venom - 7
Darkstar - 7
Kraven the Hunter - 7
The Angel (Golden Age) - 7
Eternity - 7
Ultimate Cable - 7
Clea - 7
Elixir - 7
Trauma - 7
Doc Samson - 7
Shatterstar - 7
The Bamfs - 7
Mantis - 7
Mockingbird - 7
Annihilus - 7
White Tiger - 7
Brother's Grimm - 7
Spiral - 7
Werewolf by Night - 7
Puma - 7
Nuklo - 7
Hydro-Man - 7
Sage - 7
Maestro - 7
Paste-Pot Pete - 7
Stegron - 7
Black Widow (Yelena Belova) - 7
Merc (New Universe) - 7
Paladin - 7
Justice (New Universe) - 7
336. Polestar - 6
Cerise - 6
Omega the Unknown - 6
Speed - 6
Sharon Carter - 6
Wild Child - 6
Mysterio - 6
Deathlok - 6
Mimic - 6
Rhintrah - 6
Devil Slayer - 6
3D Man - 6
Ultimate Captain Marvel - 6
Skids - 6
D-Man - 6
NFL Superpro - 6
Sentinels - 6
Ronan - 6
Hawkeye (Kate Bishop) - 6
Ultimate Wolverine - 6
Goblin 2099 - 6
Goliath (Bill Foster) - 6
Anole - 6
Swordsman - 6
Vincente - 6
Stepford Cuckoos - 6
Night Thrasher (Dwayne Taylor) - 6
Mrs. Frank Castle - 6
Rockslide - 6
365. Zombie Colonol America - 5
Lady Sif - 5
Pixie (New X-Men) - 5
Umar - 5
Colleen Wing - 5
Corsair - 5
Ultimate Gwen Stacy - 5
It, the Living Colossus - 5
Wind Dancer - 5
Mercury - 5
Bi-Beast - 5
Poundcakes - 5
Funny Face (MC2) - 5
Devil Dinosaur and Moon Boy - 5
American Eagle - 5
Swarm - 5
Callisto - 5
Warpath (James Proudstar) - 5
Lucy in the Sky (Karolina Dean) - 5
The Vulture - 5
Sabretooth (AoA) - 5
Weasel - 5
Doorman - 5
Draon Man - 5
Husk - 5
Artie - 5
Batroc ze Leaper - 5
Dakota North - 5
Wraith (Kree) - 5
Willie Lumpkin - 5
Stick - 5
Count Nefaria - 5
Dr Spectrum (Supreme Power) - 5
The Lizard - 5
399. Ego the Living Planet - 4
Elsa Bloodstone - 4
Snowbird - 4
Ultimate Falcon - 4
Code: Blue - 4
Alex Wilder - 4
Rawhide Kid - 4
Nighthawk (Supreme Power version) - 4
Zombie Iron Man - 4
Legion - 4
Leech - 4
Gate - 4
Jack O'Lantern - 4
Kro of the Deviants - 4
Tom Thumb - 4
White Rabbit - 4
Woodgod - 4
Stan Lee - 4
Molecule Man - 4
Blind Al - 4
Maverick - 4
Mammoth - 4
Ultimate Thing - 4
Gamorra - 4
Rage - 4
Spider-Woman (Mattie Franklin) - 4
Victoria Bentley - 4
Crystal - 4
Dust - 4
Stained Glass Scarlet - 4
Midnight's Fire - 4
430. Slyde - 3
Danielle Jones - 3
Dr. Abraham Erskine - 3
Terror - 3
Thundra - 3
The Destroyer - 3
Atlas - 3
Ultimate Human Torch - 3
Squidboy - 3
Hulk 2099 - 3
Martha Johannsson's Brain and Ernst - 3
Patriot - 3
Absorbing Man - 3
Sporr, the Thing that Lived - 3
Doctor Spectrum - 3
The Living Totem - 3
Tike Alicar - 3
Man-Ape - 3
Armor - 3
Ultimate Aunt May Parker - 3
The Chicago Morlocks - 3
Ultimate Mr. Fantastic - 3
Arcade - 3
Lady Mastermind - 3
454. Misty Knight - 2
Xavin - 2
Moonstone - 2
Arnim Zola - 2
Catseye - 2
Radius - 2
Cylcone - 2
Scorpio/Jake Fury - 2
Typhoid Mary - 2
The Leader - 2
Klaw - 2
Ultimate Silver Surfer - 2
Split Second Squad - 2
Mole Man - 2
Fixer/Techno - 2
Kaine - 2
Irving Forbush - 2
Silver Sable - 2
Mojo - 2
Heavy - 2
Sersi - 2
Tabitha Smith - 2
Livewires - 2
477. Korvac - 1
Empath - 1
Plantman - 1
Freedom Ring - 1
Dum Dum Dugan - 1
Ultimate Sinister - 1
Bloodstone (Ulysses Bloodstone) - 1
Bob: Agent of Hydra - 1
Nighthawk (Squadron Supreme) - 1
The Wizard - 1
Box (Madison Jeffries) - 1
Balder the Brave - 1
The Looter - 1
Foolkiller - 1
Sunspot - 1
Joan the Mouse - 1
Skullfire - 1
The Zodiac - 1
Thunderbolt Ross - 1
Blazing Skull - 1
The Prowler - 1
Phat - 1
John the Skrull - 1
Sabreclaw - 1
Krog - 1
Darwin - 1
Thunderbird - 1
Jackal - 1
Man-Killer - 1
Blinfold - 1
Nosferata - 1
Skrull Kill Krew - 1
The Ameridroid - 1
Jane Foster - 1