For the three people who were curious, here is the final tallies for the 499 DC characters I received votes for.
Enjoy!
Batman (Bruce Wayne) - 2527 (118)
Superman (All Star - 100 (1)) - 1326 (49)
Flash (Wally West) - 1275 (30)
Green Lantern (Hal Jordan) (1 Spectre) - 1091 (25)
The Joker - 797 (9)
Robin/Nightwing (Dick Grayson) - 665 (11)
Green Arrow (Oliver Queen) - 552 (12)
Wonder Woman - 542 (13)
Robin (Tim Drake) - 502 (3)
Oracle (Barbara Gordon) (79 (1) for Batgirl) - 470 (3)
Martian Manhunter (J'onn J'onzz) - 438 (5)
Booster Gold - 428 (7)
The Question (Vic Sage) - 395 (4)
Starman (Jack Knight) - 376 (12)
Blue Beetle (Ted Kord) - 370 (6)
Green Lantern (Kyle Rayner) - 364 (6)
Rorschach - 363 (5)
Black Canary - 352 (4)
Lex Luthor (All Star - 11) - 344 (1)
John Constantine - 344 (8)
Hawkman (Katar Hol - 47 (2), Carter Hall - 278 (4)) - 325 (6)
Animal Man - 325 (7)
Dream/Morpheus - 322 (2)
Zatanna - 307 (3)
Green Lantern (Guy Gardner) - 303 (4)
Darkseid - 293 (3)
Captain Marvel (Billy Batson) - 289 (5)
Power Girl - 289 (5)
Flash (Barry Allen) - 281 (4)
Aquaman (Orin) - 269 (6)
Catwoman - 251 (1)
Jesse Custer - 230 (9)
Death - 229 (2)
Spider Jerusalem - 225 (9)
Swamp Thing (Alec Holland) - 225 (3)
Firestorm (201 (4) for Ronnie/Professor, 8 for Ronnie/Arkadi) - 209(4)
Green Lantern (Alan Scott) - 196 (3)
Black Adam - 195
Yorick Brown - 186 (2)
Deathstroke the Terminator - 171
Flash (Jay Garrick) - 170 (1)
Bart Allen Impulse/Kid Flash - 169 (5)
Bizarro - 169
Plastic Man - 163 (3)
Jonah Hex - 162 (5)
Elongated Man (16 for Ralph and Sue) - 153 (1)
Ambush Bug - 157 (6)
The Spectre (Jim Corrigan) - 149 (1)
Mr. Miracle (Scott Free) - 147
Huntress (Helena Bertenelli - 125 (2), Helena Wayne - 19) - 144 (1)
Deadshot - 138 (3)
Lobo - 134 (3)
Hitman - 134 (3)
Harley Quinn - 132
Speedy/Arsenal/Red Arrow (Roy Harper) - 129 (2)
Superboy (Connor Kent) - 128 (2)
Sandman (Wesley Dodds) - 125 (3)
Supergirl (Kara) - 124 (2)
Wildcat (Ted Grant) - 118 (4)
Brainiac Five (83 (1) original, 21 (1) first reboot, 7 second reboot) - 111 (2)
Robotman (Cliff Steele) - 106 (3)
Dr. Fate - 105
Batgirl (Cassandra Cain) - 105 (2)
Atom (Ray Palmer) - 105
Starfire - 104 (1)
The Riddler - 103 (1)
Jimmy Olsen (All Star Jimmy - 11) - 101 (1)
Manhunter (Kate Spencer) - 101
Donna Troy - 101
Adam Strange - 100
Mary Marvel - 98
Amanda Waller - 96 (3)
Blue Beetle (Jaime Reyes) - 93
Raven - 91 (2)
Dr. Manhattan - 90
Bigby Wolf - 89 (2)
Proinsais Cassidy - 89 (1)
Beast Boy - 87 (2)
Mr Terrific (Michael Holt) - 85 (1)
Green Lantern (John Stewart) - 83
James Gordon - 82 (1)
Lucifer - 80 (3)
Red Tornado - 78 (1)
Harvey Dent/Two-Face - 77 (1)
Kilowog - 75
The Metal Men - 72
Lois Lane - 70
Alfred Pennyworth - 70 (1)
Ozymandias - 69
Big Barda - 68
Phantom Stranger - 68
Captain Atom - 66 (1)
Orion - 66
Sgt. Rock - 64
Cyborg - 64
Stargirl - 63
Deadman - 62 (1)
Mr. Mxyzptlk - 62
Metamorpho - 61
Hawkgirl - 61 (1)
101. Etrigan the Demon - 56
Delirium - 56
103. Solomon Grundy - 54
104. Renee Montoya - 53 (1)
105. Wildfire (Pre-ZH) - 51 (3)
Scarecrow - 51
107. Sinestro - 50
108. Matter-Eater Lad (Pre-ZH) - 49
109. Batman (Dark Knight Returns) - 48 (1)
Detective Chimp - 48 (2)
111. Catman (Thomas Blake) - 46
Crazy Jane - 46
The Saint of Killers - 46
114. Vixen - 45
115. Poison Ivy - 44 (1)
The Shade - 44 (1)
Ravager (Rose Wilson) - 44
Timber Wolf (Pre-ZH) - 44
Superman (Kingdom Come) - 44
120. Ra's Al Ghul - 43
121. Dr. Mid-Nite (Pieter Cross) - 42
122. Warlord (Travis Morgan) - 41 (3)
King Mob - 41
124. Steel (John Henry Irons) - 40 (1)
Shade The Changing Man (Ditko) - 40 (2)
126. Cyborg Superman (Hank Henshaw) - 39
OMAC (original) - 39
128. Kamandi - 38 (1)
129. Enemy Ace - 37 (1)
Manhunter (Paul Kirk) - 37
131. Gorilla Grodd - 36
Uncle Sam - 36
Captain Cold - 36
Krypto - 36 (1)
We3 - 36
The Ray (Ray Terrill) - 36 (1)
The Creeper - 36
138. Zoom (Hunter Zolomon) - 35
139. Supergirl (Matrix) - 34
Boy Blue - 34
Spoiler - 34
142. Ultra Boy (31 pre-ZH, 2 post-ZH) - 33
Arseface - 33 (1)
Azrael - 33 (1)
Grace - 33
146. Ragman - 32 (1)
Hawkwoman - 32 (1)
Mon-El (Lar Gand) (pre-ZH) - 32
Capitan Boomerang (Digger Harkness) - 32
Liberty Belle/Jesse Quick (Jesse Chambers) - 32
Tim Hunter - 32
152. Aqualad/Tempest - 31
153. Herr Starr - 30
154. Nuklon/Atom Smasher - 29
155. Damage - 28 (1)
Green Arrow (Connor Hawke) - 28
157. Lord Fanny - 27 (1)
Green Lantern (Mogo) - 27
Jason Todd - 27
Pied Piper (Hartley Rathaway) - 27 (1)
161. Fire - 26
Hourman (Rex Tyler) - 26
163. Blue Devil - 25
164. Aquaman, Sword of Atlantis - 24
The Trickster (James Jesse) - 24
166. Zauriel - 23
Batwoman (Katherine Kane) - 23
Bane - 23
Miss Martian - 23
170. Atom (Ryan Choi) - 22
Doomsday - 22
G'nort - 22 (1)
Danny the Street - 22
Karate Kid (Original - 22) - 22
175. Cosmic Boy (Original - 9 Post-ZH - 3 Threebot - 9) - 21
Agent Graves - 21
Wonder Girl (Cassie) - 21
Dawnstar - 21
Batman (All Star) - 21 (1)
180. Kid Devil (Edward Bloomberg) - 20
The Legion of Substitute Heroes - 20
Aztek - 20
183. 'Mazing Man - 19
Nite Owl (Dan Dreiberg) - 19
Rebis - 19 (1)
186. Manhunter (Shaw) - 18
Superboy Prime - 18
Ice - 18
Brainiac - 18
Star Boy/Starman (Thom Kallor) (Original) - 18
Obsidian - 18
192. The Haunted Tank - 17
Cheetah - 17
194. Manhattan Guardian - 16
Johnny Thunder (Earth 2) - 16
Cain and Abel - 16
Captain Comet - 16
The Unknown Soldier - 16
Hob Gadling - 16 (1)
Dian Belmont - 16
201. Dr. Mid-Nite (Charles McNider) - 15
Negative Man - 15 (1)
Vigilante (Adrian Chase) - 15
The Penguin - 15
Giganta - 15
Jade - 15
Destruction - 15
208. Katana - 14
Doctor 13 - 14 (1)
Tulip (Preacher) - 14
Liberty Belle (Libby Lawerence) - 14
Challengers of the Unknown - 14
Starro - 14
Ampersand - 14
Superboy (Clark Kent) - 14 (1)
Captain Marvel Jr. - 14
217. Flex Mentallo - 13
Black Lightning - 13
Slam Bradley - 13
Saturn Girl (original) - 13
Mr. Nobody - 13
Eradicator - 13
Mr. Zsasz - 13
Metron - 13 (1)
L-Ron - 13
226. Prometheus - 12
The Human Bomb (Lincoln) - 12
Prince Charming - 12
Lady Blackhawk - 12
Bat-Mite - 12 (1)
Invisible Kid (Lyle Norg) (threeboot version) - 12
The Ventriloquist & Scarface - 12
233. Ch'p - 11 (1)
Chronos (Walker Gabriel) - 11
Captain Boomerang (Owen Mercer) - 11
Grant Morrison - 11
Section 8 (Hitman) - 11
Dashiell Bad Horse - 11
Waverider - 11 (1)
Matthew the Raven - 11
Red Tornado (Ma Hunkel) - 11
Inferior Five - 11
Bulleteer - 11
Triplicate Girl (Original - 7, Post-ZH - 4) - 11
Jericho (Jospeh Wilson) - 11
Risk - 11
247. Dial H for Hero - 10 (1)
Hawk and Dove (Hank Hall/Dawn Granger) 10 (1)
Thessaly the Witch - 10
Louie the Lilac - 10 (1)
Crimson Fox - 10 (1)
The Frog Prince (Fables) - 10 (1)
Vandal Savage - 10
The Adversary (Fables) - 10
Shining Knight (Sir Justin) - 10
Vril Dox II - 10
Mr. Freeze - 10
Merv Pumpkinhead - 10
Barnabas the Dog - 10 (1)
The Comedian - 10
Wild Dog - 10 (1)
Female Furies - 10 (1)
Travis Clevenger (Bloodhound) - 10 (1)
Mad Hatter - 10 (1)
Ragdoll II - 10 (1)
Arak, Son of Thunder - 10
Jensen (The Losers) - 10
268. Mark Merlin/Prince Ra-Man - 9
Starman (Ted Knight) - 9
XS - 9
Quislet - 9
Clayface - 9
Jack of Fables - 9
The Calculator - 9
Firestorm (Jason) - 9
Agent 355 - 9
Beth #2 - 9
Circe - 9
Mist II - 9
Lady Shiva - 9
Funky Flashman - 9
Ruth (from Loveless) - 9
Granny Goodness - 9
Kathy George - 9
Triumph - 9
286. Silk Spectre (Watchmen) - 8
Romy Chandler - 8
The Monolith - 8
The Manhunters - 8
Vanessa from American Virgin) - 8
Captain Carrot - 8
Zee Hernandez - 8
Pig Iron - 8
Silver Banshee - 8
Cyclone (Maxine Hunkel) - 8
Black Orchid - 8
The Brotherhood of Dada - 8
Lightning Lad (6 pre-ZH, 2 post-ZH) - 8
Ragged Robin - 8
Wonder Woman (Kingdom Come) - 8
Madame Xanadu - 8
Queen Bee - 8
Ethan Harrow - 8
Savant - 8
Phantom Girl - 8
Sand (Sandy Hawkins) - 8
Jason Blood - 8
Xero - 8
Lucien the Librarian - 8
310. Driq - 7
Batman (Red Son) - 7
Hawk & Dove (Hank and Don Hall) - 7
Knockout - 7
Human Target (Christopher Chance) - 7
New Frontier Wonder Woman - 7
Mme. Marie - 7
Agent ! - 7
Cheshire - 7
Creote - 7
Shikari - 7
Killer Frost II - 7
Polar Boy (Pre-ZH) - 7
Monsieur Mallah - 7
Matty Roth - 7
Eclipso - 7
Terra - 7
Gypsy - 7
Gilbert (Fiddler's Green) - 7
Colossal Boy - 7
Goldilocks - 7
Captain Marvel (Kingdom Come) - 7
Retro (from Grant Morrison's JLA run) - 7
Halo - 7
Batman (Red Rain) - 7
Nadira - 7
OA Guardians - 7
Manchester Black - 7
Sebastian Faust - 7
339. Toyman - 6
Gangbuster - 6
Vigilante (Western) - 6
Ravan - 6
Marcus Driver - 6
Green Lantern (Katma Tui) - 6
Shadow Lass (Pre-ZH) - 6
Psycho Pirate - 6
Merlyn - 6
Bumblebee - 6
Sue Dibny - 6
Validus (pre-Zero Hour) - 6
Amethyst - 6
Wildebeest - 6
Major Disaster - 6
Black Alice - 6
Mr. Terrific (Terry Sloane) - 6
Prez - 6
Dr. Allison Mann - 6
Strange Visitor - 6
Scooter - 6
Desire - 6
Bat Lash - 6
Cornelius Stirk - 6
Bouncing Boy (Original LSH) - 6
364. Element Lad - 5
Nemesis - 5
Batman/Tharok hybrid - 5
Sex Detectives (Preacher) - 5
Rainbow Raider - 5
Green Lantern (Tomar Re) - 5
Terry McGinnis Batman - 5
Dream Girl (Pre-Zero Hour) - 5
Egg Fu - 5
Anti-Monitor - 5
Manhunter (DePaul) - 5
Frankenstein - 5
Angel O'Day - 5
Lex Luthor (Red Son) - 5
Kid Eternity (original) - 5
Steel (New Frontier) - 5
Gamemnae - 5
Atom (Al Pratt) - 5
Resurrection Man (Mitch Shelley) - 5
Anti-Monitor - 5
Arrowette - 5
Tigorr - 5
Klarion - 5
Secret - 5
Bronze Tiger - 5
Enchantress - 5
Jack T. Chance - 5
Jack O' Lantern Liam McHugh - 5
Charaxys - 5
393. Onomotapoiea - 4
Weird - 4
Green Lantern (Tomar-Re) - 4
Cameron Chase - 4
Phobia - 4
Sun Boy (Original) - 4
Man-Bat - 4
Geo-Force - 4
Per Degaton - 4
General Zod - 4
Anarky - 4
Misfit - 4
Rampage - 4
Isis - 4
Sam Simeon - 4
Mazikeen (from Lucifer) - 4
Superman (Red Son) - 4
Talia al Ghul - 4
Perry White - 4
Skeets - 4
Jack Frost - 4
Frau Totenkinder (Fables) - 4
Jihad (Suicide Squad) - 4
Scandal Savage - 4
Nocturna - 4
AJ (Exterminators) - 4
419. Dr. Simon LaGrieve - 3
Nathaniel Dusk - 3
Gates (Ti'julk Mr'asz) - 3
Tommy Jagger - 3
Destiny - 3
Hourman (Rick Tyler) - 3
Laurel Gand (pre-ZH) - 3
Beppo - 3
New Frontier Green Lantern - 3
Mas y Menos - 3
Kole - 3
Adam Chamberlain (American Virgin) - 3
Artemis - 3
Rip Hunter - 3
Cheeks, The Toy Wonder - 3
Lono - 3
Minute-Man - 3
Killer Croc - 3
Hector Hammond - 3
Laura Kent - 3
Time Trapper - 3
Black Manta - 3
The Smiler - 3
Roulette - 3
Wonder Woman (Kingdom Come) - 3
Manitou Raven - 3
Snow from Fables - 3
Dr Sivana - 3
447. Tellus - 2
Reverse Flash (Eobard Thawne) - 2
Manga Khan - 2
Brother Power, the Geek - 2
The Dingbats Of Danger Street - 2
Tawky Tawny (Shazam! Monster Society of Evil) - 2
Rose Red - 2
Red Robin ( Kingdom Come) - 2
Dubbilex - 2
Brother Eye - 2
Mad Mod - 2
Jinx - 2
Green Lantern (Soranik Natu) - 2
Lady Styx - 2
Joey Martin (Proposition Player) - 2
Slobo - 2
Kalibak - 2
Despair - 2
Supermen of America - 2
The Mist - 2
T.C (Preacher) - 2
468. Gleek - 1
Scarlet Skier - 1
Colonel Rumaan Harjavti - 1
Skyrocket - 1
Jody (Preacher) - 1
Stalker - 1
Young Heroes in Love - 1
I... Vampire - 1
Hush - 1
Gnaark) - 1
The Creature Commandos - 1
Fury (Earth-Two) - 1
Hoppy the Marvel Bunny - 1
Nightshade - 1
Queen of Fables - 1
Olympian - 1
Abby Cable - 1
Lien Harper - 1
Argent - 1
Chronos (Villain) - 1
Hero (Y the Last Man) - 1
Starman (Mikaal Thomas) - 1
Hacken - 1
Number None - 1
Shrinking Violet (Post-ZH) - 1
Sensor Girl (pre-ZH) - 1
Alanna Strange - 1
The Enigma - 1
Composite Superman - 1
Vext - 1
The Heckler - 1
Ferro Lad - 1