The Eisner nominations are out, so bring on the snark!

Let's take a look ...

Here is the list of Eisner nominations for this year.  I don't know much about the history of the awards, nor do I particularly care, but they seem pretty good.  I haven't read a lot of the nominees, but they always seem well-received by those bloggers who are far smarter than I am, and the ones I have read are certainly worthy of recognition, even if I might choose differently.

But we are here to tear down, not build up!  Your mission, should you choose to accept it, is to name one (1) and only ONE (1) nominee that does not belong at all.  It must be something you have read personally, because if you simply THINK something does not belong, people will come here and pick on you (as I know from bitter, bitter experience)!  And I don't want to get too crazy ripping the list to shreds, so please limit yourself to ONE choice.  Plus, give me a replacement!  Mine is ...

Hatter M: The Looking Glass Wars for Best Limited Series.  I enjoyed the series, and think it's a fun read, but there is no way it's one of the five best limited series from last year.  Templesmith's art is always good, but he got nominated in another category, and the story just doesn't hold up well enough to nominate it.  My choice to replace it: if you want to go Big Two, The American Way, but if you want to go small press, The Middleman vol. 2.

All right, people, fire away!  Which one nomination is a joke, and how would you fix it?

X-Menogamy: Did Marvel Quietly Make Wolverine, Cyclops & Jean Polyamorous?

More in Comics