There are some heavy-hitting heroes in the DC universe, from the super-powerful Superman to the ever intelligent Batman. The Boys, meanwhile, have their own form of superpowered heroes, even if the term hero can be applied loosely to them. The question is, how would Black Noir fare in DC?
On one hand, he should be able to handle most, if not all of the street-level heroes. On the other, it's hard to see him standing up against the more cosmic ones, especially when using the television show version of the character who is a fair bit weaker than his comic counterpart.
10 Destroy: Nightwing
While he's not as strong as his mentor Batman, Nightwing is far from a weak hero, able to hold his own against even more alien threats. That said, it's hard to see him able to stand toe to toe with Black Noir, who has combat capabilities that more than match Dick's, but also has an imperviousness to pain.
Add in the healing factor he has, and there's no way Nightwing could put him down, especially with his unwillingness to kill.
9 Destroy Him: Flash
The Flash is a hero that's a hard matchup for just about anyone in comics, let alone Black Noir. His speed makes him incredibly difficult for anyone who isn't a speedster to keep up with, a big reason why many of Flash's villains are just that, especially in his television show.
For all of Black Noir's combat prowess, he simply wouldn't be able to catch up with Flash, and the fight would be incredibly one-sided. Even with a degree of prep, Flash still wouldn't have too many issues.
8 Destroy: Batgirl
As with Nightwing, Batgirl is a very talented combatant, one who often gets underrated due to the presence of Batman. She is also the most tech-savvy character in the Bat-family, as shown during her time as Oracle.
Unfortunately, that isn't going to help her in a battle with the silent assassin, Black Noir. Noir has her beat in just about every category, from strength to martial arts to his durability. He also has no qualms about killing her, giving him the instant advantage of not having to hold back.
7 Destroy Him: Superman
This is self-explanatory, for as strong as the characters are in The Boys, none of them could stand up to the man in blue, not even the great Homelander. Superman has more superpowers than you can shake a stick at, making him a boring character to some.
This isn't a battle of popularity though, it's one of combat prowess, and in that realm, Superman would wipe the floor with him. This fight would only last as long as Supes allowed it.
6 Destroy: Damian Wayne
Trained from birth to be the pinnacle assassin, Damian Wayne is one of the stronger street-level characters around and someone that could go blow for blow with Black Noir. Their battle would be incredibly intense, the two of them willing to go to depths that other DC heroes wouldn't.
What this battle would come down to is the durability that Black Noir has. His inability to feel pain would allow him to continue unhindered despite whatever injury was inflicted on him.
5 Destroy Him: Wonder Woman
When you consider what Queen Maeve was able to do to Black Noir, Wonder Woman shouldn't have much of an issue. While yes, she isn't going to force-feed him an Almond Joy, she has a greater level of strength than he does.
No amount of pain tolerance can stop your bones from breaking under the pressure of her strikes. For as well regarded as The Seven are in The Boys, they aren't actual gods, unlike Diana is. As with Superman, this battle only goes on as long as she allows it.
4 Destroy: Beast Boy
Beast Boy has a lot of tools in his arsenal, capable of changing into whatever animal he desires. It makes him more formidable an opponent then people give him credit for.
That said, Black Noir may not even have to worry about them when you consider how skilled he is at stealth. He could get the drop on Beast Boy and take him out before the young Teen Titan had a chance to prepare himself.
3 Destroy Him: Supergirl
Kryptonians are simply out of Black Noir's power range, possessing powers that dwarf his. He can have all of the healing, stealth, and pain suppression that he wants, but none of it would matter if he was taking a gust from her freeze breath or a blast of her heat vision.
That doesn't even account for how powerful her punches are, strong enough to shatter Black Noir's bones with ease. He'd be left a bloody pulp after scrapping with Kara.
2 Destroy: Green Arrow
You can't discredit Green Arrow's talents, as his array of arrows can be a difficulty for more than a few heroes, especially when coupled with his level of accuracy. He can take a target out from both a distance and up close and personal.
If given prep and details on Black Noir's abilities, he might be too much for the skilled ninja. Without it, he's at a massive disadvantage. All you need is one look at Ollie to know what he can do.
1 Destroy Him: Green Lantern
Cosmic level heroes are always going to manhandle street-level characters unless they have some easily exposed weakness like Superman does with Kryptonite. Green Lantern doesn't have that same issue once they eliminated his weakness to certain colors.
Black Noir's best hope would be trying to outlast the lantern, an impossible feat, even with his powers. There's only so much of a beating that the body can take before it gives out, no matter how high your pain tolerance is. Make no mistake either, this battle would be a beating from start to finish.