Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark is a frightening (and occasionally boring) horror film. 1 / 8
Director André Øvredal excels during the horrific moments... 2 / 8
... giving each creature a real sense of dread. 3 / 8
But the script can't nail down the smaller character beats... 4 / 8
Leaving lots of storytelling potential fall by the wayside. 5 / 8
The film is still a visually impressive scarefest... 6 / 8
But it's a little disappointing, given the potential it sets up. 7 / 8
Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark is in theaters now. 8 / 8