Fishing, a new mechanic introduced in Red Dead Redemption 2, allows the player can catch and hunt fish for quests, sport or money. Cooking and eating fish also restores health, stamina or Dead Eye cores. It's also just a fun way to waste a few hours in one of the most gorgeous games to release in the past decade.
In total, there are 15 types of fish, with each having its own Legendary version. Fish differ in weight and size when caught and most are specific to one region. Talking to Jeremy Gill will activate the Legendary Fish Quest and by using specific lures while following the map, Arthur can travel the country to find the biggest and best catches.
How to Find the Legendary Fish Quest
After completing ''A Fisher of Men,'' the player will see a Stranger location marker in The Heartlands, close to Flatneck Station. Here they will find Jeremy Gill, a self-proclaimed legendary fisherman. He asks Arthur if he would like a photograph or autograph before showing off the inside of his cabin, where he makes a living by selling stuffed fish. This starts the ''A Fisher of Fish'' quest.
He then proceeds to give Arthur the map of all the Legendary Fish sites. Stating he will pay a handsome price in exchange, he asks Arthur to collect 13 fish for him. After completing the first part of the mission, the player can later return to Jeremy to help him hunt a giant catfish in Río Bravo.
How to Catch a Legendary Fish
The primary tool for fishing is the fishing rod, which is unlocked as the player progresses through the story, specifically when fishing with Jack Marston in ''A Fisher of Men.'' However, it can be unlocked earlier by knocking it out of the hands of a fishing NPC, although the Legendary Fish quest doesn't start until after ''A Fisher of Men'' is complete.
To catch Legendary Fish, the player will need specific Lures based on the area the fish is located, such as in a river or swamp. It is recommended to visit the Bait & Tackle Shop in Lagras as it sells all the types of bait and lures available, including ones for non-legendary fish. Catching a Legendary Fish is the same as catching a normal fish. When using a Lure, the player needs to slowly reel the lure in to make it look alive to fish, then wait until the fish bites before hooking it in.
Where to Find All the Legendary Fish
Legendary Bluegill - The Legendary Bluegill is located around Scarlet Meadows at Flat Iron Lake and is attracted using Special Lake Lures. It is rumored that it is more likely to be caught during rainy weather. As it is located on the Southbank, there's a chance of catching it while fishing with Kieran in Chapter 3 if the player uses the lure.
Legendary Bullhead Catfish - The Legendary Bullhead Catfish is located at Sisika Penitentiary, East of Saint Denis and can be caught using Special River Lures. It's most active when it's raining and can weigh around six pounds. As Siska Penitentiary is a restricted area, it is one of the most dangerous and difficult fish to catch.
Legendary Chain Pickerel - The Legendary Chain Pickerel is found in the Dakota River, South-West of Valentine and West of Limpany. Caught with Special River Lures, it is more likely to be caught on sunny days.
Legendary Lake Sturgeon - The Legendary Lake Sturgeon is found in South-West Saint Denis on the Lannahechee River and is caught using River Lures. To catch the Sturgeon, the player should either stand off the railroad bridge or row out to the area. Care should be taken in this area as the player could end up stranded on one of the small islands with the fish if using a canoe.
Legendary Largemouth Bass - The Legendary Largemouth Bass inhabits the San Luis River and is caught during rainy weather using Special River Lures. It is one of the Legendary Fish not available to be caught until after the Epilogue.
Legendary Longnose Gar - The Legendary Longnose Gar can be found in the swamp area of Bayou Nwa, beside Lakay and Lagras. Using a Special Swamp Lure and fishing during overcast weather will attract the Gar.
Legendary Muskie - The Legendary Muskie can be caught near the Van Horn Trading Post on the Lannahechee River. Using a Special River Lure on an overcast day will increase the chances of catching the Muskie.
Legendary Northern Pike - The Legendary Northern Pike can be found near O'Creagh's Run. Using Special Lake Lures and fishing on an overcast day is the best way to catch it. It can only be caught in the stranger mission ''The Veteran - II'' and is nicknamed ''Tyrant'' by Hamish Sinclair.
Legendary Perch - The Legendary Perch can be found in the Elysian Pool South-West of Annesburg. It is caught using Special Lake Lures in sunnier weather. The Perch appears to be diseased, much like the other animals around this area, which is likely due to the contaminated habitat.
Legendary Redfin Pickerel - The Legendary Redfin Pickerel is located in Stillwater Creek next to Thieves Landing. Like other Pickerel, it prefers warm sunny weather and a Lake or River Lure can be used to catch it. It is one of the Legendary Fish not available to be caught until after the Epilogue.
Legendary Rock Bass - The Legendary Rock Bass is located in the Aurora Basin and can be caught using lake or river lures on sunny days. It is one of the Legendary Fish not available to be caught until after the Epilogue.
Legendary Smallmouth Bass - The Legendary Smallmouth Bass is found in the waters of Owanjila, next to Strawberry. The player should use a Special Lake Lure and fish when it is raining for a successful catch.
Legendary Sockeye Salmon - The Legendary Sockeye Salmon is found in Lake Isabella, specifically where the lake meets Beartooth River. The player will need a Special Lake Lure and to fish on an overcast day. The Salmon can weigh in at over 50 pounds.
Legendary Steelhead Trout -The Legendary Steelhead Trout can be found near Willard's Rest, North of Annesburg. Trout are known for being more active during rainy weather, and it's best to use a Special River Lure to catch.