Since it was announced that Amazon and EA were nearing a deal for a Mass Effect series, longtime fans and former writers have been debating whether or not the project is a good idea. In the midst of the discussions come former lead writer Drew Karpyshyn and composer Sam Hulick, who have expressed interest in being involved in the adaptation.On social media, Karpyshyn responded to news of the Mass Effect series by writing, "I'm not involved, but I'm looking forward to it!" He added, "Happy to consult if they want my input." Hulick also posted, "I'm gonna throw my hat in the ring on this one."
Karpyshyn was served as lead writer on the first Mass Effect game and its sequel. In addition, he wrote several novels that expanded on the story of the video game franchise, including a prequel, Mass Effect: Revelation, detailing Saren's backstory and his relationship with Captain Anderson. Karpyshyn also wrote Mass Effect: Ascension and Mass Effect: Retribution, which bridged the games. The novels were generally well-received as tie-ins.
Hulick worked on all three games in the original Mass Effect trilogy as composer. Much of the first game's soundtrack was produced by Hulick and Jack Wall, as well as Richard Jacques. Mass Effect 2 saw the return of both Hulick and Wall, with additional music provided by Jimmy Hinson and David Kates. The score of Mass Effect 3 saw Hulick return once again, working alongside Sascha Dikiciyan and Cris Velasco.
Not all members of the video games' creative teams have been so positive about the prospect of a live-action adaptation. Former Bioware writer David Gaider expressed his doubts about the success of a Mass Effect series, if it were to adapt the events of the games. He argued that the trilogy was made to give players control over the central character, Commander Shepard, as well as certain events, meaning that an attempt to adapt that and establish certain characteristics about the character would alienate certain fans. He also believed that the show would be forced to reduce certain stories and characters. Similar arguments have been made by fans debating the advantages and disadvantages of a Mass Effect adaptation. Ultimately, Gaider said, "The possibility... makes me cringe just a little."
No official announcements have been made concerning the plot of the series. As of yet, it has only been reported that EA and Amazon are closing in on a deal for Mass Effect. It's uncertain if the show will adapt the events and characters of the series.