The Nickelodeon lineup of animation from the late 20th/early 21st century was a unique one, introducing audiences to cartoonish characters like the cast of SpongeBob SquarePants or wacky worlds like The Fairly OddParents. A popular entry in that canon was the relatively down-to-earth Hey Arnold, which traded zany antics for more character-based storytelling.

However, there was one genre this series nailed beyond any of its peers: horror. Despite being largely innocent and down-to-earth in conception, Hey Arnold was quietly a strong contender for the American animated show with the most effective scary episodes.

Hey Arnold Horror Episodes 5

Created by Craig Bartlett, Hey Arnold originally ran for eight years on Nickelodeon. The show was nominally centered on the titular Arnold, a well-meaning and soft-spoken young man living in the city of Hillwood alongside his best friend Gerald and his local bully Helga. Growing up in his grandparents' boarding house, Arnold spent the series trying to survive early crushes at school, dealing with the problems of his friends and neighbors and unknowingly being a romantic obsession for Helga.

RELATED: Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl Channels Super SMASHING Bros. Energy

It was a largely down-to-earth show, where the cartoonish elements were downplayed in exchange for more dramatic and realistic stakes. The threats were often the products of aggressive bullies, rumors escalating into frightening misconceptions and the occasional unexplainable and frightening weirdo.

The exception to this rule throughout the series were its urban legend episodes. Each of the episodes followed a similar general structure. Someone -- typically Gerald or Grandpa -- would lay out a surprisingly dark and oftentimes supernatural story. Arnold and his friends would then find themselves trapped in a situation eerily similar to the one they've heard of.

The cast would escape their situation just barely and discover its benign reality, only for there to be final hints that the supernatural elements might not just be a story. These stories were often surprisingly grim for the young audience that the series was aimed at, with subjects like a murderous gangster named Wheezin' Ed or an ax-wielding Ghost Bride.

RELATED: Avatar: The Last Airbender, ICarly Will Eventually Be Paramount+ Exclusives

In a series that was often defined by its relatively human stakes, these horror episodes were genuinely unsettling, partly in how different they felt from the rest of the series. The other element was that Hey Arnold as a whole always succeeded in terms of conveying a variety of tones well, with the quietly creepy atmosphere of these episodes elevating their sudden jump scares. The climaxes -- often hinting at their genuine validity -- only added to this memorable feeling of unease as the episode ended and no amount of schooling, friendship or life lessons were going to help you if you found yourself aboard the fabled haunted train.

"The Headless Cabbie" might be the ultimate example of this style in the series. Gerald's tells the story of a monstrous woman who tricked a carriage driver into getting himself killed, and then their spirits continue to haunt the cobblestone park. This conveys a childish level of authenticity and frightening imagery, and its final moments end on the creepy implication that the boys escaped meeting the spirit, only for her to seemingly arrive at the carriage unnoticed, prepared to take another life. Other similar episodes -- "Ghost Train," "Ghost Bride," "Wheezin' Ed," "Four-Eyed Jack" "Sid the Vampire Slayer" and "Arnold's Halloween" all add up to the series having some of American animation's most effective horror episodes.

KEEP READING: Avatar Creators Have Decades' Worth Of Stories To Tell