Quick Links

Summary

  • The 2021 movie adaptation of Dune, though better liked by audiences and critics, makes one of the same mistakes as its 1984 predecessor.
  • The dinner party scene from Frank Herbert's original novel includes bits of political intrigue and important worldbuilding that should have been in the movie adaptations.
  • In addition to the dinner party sequence, both Dune adaptations leave out major parts of Frank Herbert's iconic book.

Dune began as a landmark science fiction novel by Frank Herbert, with the title having now received multiple adaptations. The latest of these was the 2021 Dune movie by Denis Villeneuve, which retold roughly the first half of the book's story on the big screen. It didn't capture every scene from the books, however, with several pivotal elements missing from the finalized version of the movie.

Most notably, Dune 2021 was missing a particularly important scene from the original novel. Ironically, this same scene was also absent from the David Lynch-directed Dune movie from 1984. This is despite Herbert commenting on the original movie not having this scene, let alone its place in the book's story. Strangely enough, for as accurate as the Villeneuve version was to the source material, this was actually only one of several "missing scenes."

Updated by Jordan Iacobucci on March 8, 2024: Dune: Part Two is finally in theaters, completing Denis Villeneuve's epic cinematic adaptation of Frank Herbert's classic 1965 sci-fi novel. Taking things up a notch from the 2021 film, the sequel depicts the final battle between Paul Atreides and the villainous Harkonnens. While Villenueve's adaptation is far more faithful to the source material than David Lynch's 1984 adaptation, there are still some key scenes from Herbert's book that are missing from the big screen versions.

Dune 1984 Was a Contentious Adaptation of a Sci-Fi Classic

Related
How the Dune Trilogy Will Become The Modern Lord of the Rings
The Lord of the Rings changed the fantasy film genre forever and Dune will become the next trilogy to alter the face of film adaptations.

Trivia

  • 1984's Dune was intended to launch a franchise based on Frank Herbert's works. A sequel would have adapted the events of Dune: Messiah, but never came to fruition after the original film bombed at the box office.

The original movie adaptation of Dune is now considered an ambitious cult classic, namely for those who enjoy science fiction movies from the 1980s. Nevertheless, the original Dune has its critics, be they professionals or merely fans of the source material. Part of the reason for certain complaints was the sometimes egregious changes made when transitioning from the book to the big screen. In particular, the handling of Baron Vladimir Harkonnon was seen as making him a cackling cartoon villain who traded his original depth for a disgusting, grotesque aesthetic.

Famed film critic Roger Ebert referred to David Lynch's Dune as "an incomprehensible, ugly, unstructured, pointless excursion into the murkier realms of one of the most confusing screenplays of all time." He was certainly not alone in his dislike of the movie, with the consensus claiming it as one of the biggest missteps in cinematic history. Even Lynch shared this sentiment, once saying, "I'm proud of everything -- except Dune."

Author Frank Herbert, on the other hand, was very pleased with Lynch's handling of the vast source material. Dune's original manuscript was passed over almost two dozen times. The initial critical reception was horrendous, so the author became accustomed to negative analysis. The only regret he mentioned was the omission of the book's banquet scene, which laid the foundation for later parts of the plot. This scene was also missing from Denis Villeneuve's latest adaptation. Comparisons between the two Dune films aside, the moment Herbert longed for could have added something of great value to both films.

Frank Herbert's Dune Novel Builds Political Tension

Related
8 Dune Actors Who Are Also in the Marvel Cinematic Universe
Denis Villeneuve's Dune might not have much in common with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, but the two franchises share some truly talented actors.

Trivia

  • In 2000, a miniseries entitled Frank Herbert's Dune aired on the Sci-Fi Channel. The miniseries was widely praised and its 2003 successor, Children of Dune, later adapted the second and third of Frank Herbert's books.

In the lead-up to the banquet scene, Duke Leto, the newly arrived Lord of Arrakis and military commander Gurney Halleck use the ornithopter vehicle to rescue a group of spice miners. This moment defines the Duke's character in direct juxtaposition to his Harkonnen predecessor by demonstrating that his subjects' lives are more important than the almost full load of spice that was sacrificed to secure their safety. It also sharpens the clarity of just how tenuous their position on Arrakis is because it is clear that rescue was only necessary due to sabotage.

The next chapter is entirely dedicated to a dinner planned by Lady Jessica, the Duke's concubine and a Bene Gesserit adept. She is acutely aware of their precarious hold on power and produces a guest list that she thinks will engender stronger political relationships that will prove necessary for their survival. Thufir Hawat, the Duke's devoted mentat and Master of Assassins, did not attend and was adamant that the Duke abstain as well, in part because he has made it a poorly kept secret that he thinks, erroneously, that Lady Jessica is a Harkonnen spy.

While Leto watches the preparations take place, he absently wonders if anyone will try to kill him in the coming evening. After Leto notices a servant preparing a bowl of water and towels for a custom instituted by the Harkonnens, he abolishes the practice on sight, only fueling the simmering anger from the carryall debacle. He then greets his guests.

Dune's Dinner Scene Shows Appearances Can Be Deceiving

Lady Jessica (Rebecca Ferguson) and Paul Atreides (Timothee Chalamet) stand side by side in Dune
Related
10 Most Powerful Quotes From Dune: Part Two
Dune Part 2 is a powerful film that features incredible quotes from characters like Paul, Lady Jessica, and Chani.

Trivia

  • In 1966, Frank Herbert's Dune became the first book ever to win the annual Nebula Award for Best Novel.

As ducal heir Paul Atreides attends the dinner party, it soon becomes clear that he is surrounded by various shadowy figures, each with their agendas. Duncan Idaho, the champion of House Atreides, is there to spy on Lady Jessica for Thufir Hawat. The Bene Gesserit-trained Lady Jessica is there hosting and manipulating, trying to acquaint herself with someone who may be able to get House Atreides off-world quickly.

Many of the party guests are mercantile and economic stakeholders, both legal and illicit. The scene allows for some very crucial world-building for Dune's later stories. In introducing a series of seemingly unrelated characters as a part of the dinner party, Dune deconstructs the sci-fi genre by adding an element of political intrigue. During the party, a water oligarch named Lingar Bewt makes it quite clear he has no fondness for the Duke or his changing of customs and is more than willing to remind any about his leverage over the planet; An unnamed agent of the Guild Bank who serves as an adviser to the Water Peddler's Union is secretly a Harkonnen spy; Esmar Tuek is a renowned and well-connected smuggler. Lastly, Liet Kynes is there, the Judge of Change and a prominent planetologist, who carries the controversial belief that Arrakis could be successfully terraformed into a water-abundant planet.

The Duke gives a brusque toast while a bevy of rich foods, imported sparkling wine, and coffee spiked with mélange grace the table. The Duke then drinks half of his water and pours the rest onto the floor. Custom demands that his guests follow suit, and many display obvious discomfort at the waste of it all. Kynes, however, casually pours him into a hidden container.

Related
Why Riding Sandworms Is So Crucial to Dune: Part Two
Sandworms play a key part of Dune's storyline, especially Paul Atreide's ascent to power. Dune: Part Two reveals the reasons for his wild ride.

Trivia

  • Both Tim Blake Nelson and Stephen McKinley Henderson were meant to appear in Dune: Part Two but were ultimately cut from the film. Henderson would have reprised his role of Thufir Hawat from the original film, while Nelson's character was unconfirmed.

This scene is much more than worldbuilding for the Dune series. Throughout the gathering, trepidatious conversation bubbles up while Jessica and Paul herd the various players to their spots on the stage without the performers realizing that their parts have been cast. As a result, this scene works well in showcasing Paul and Jessica's effective diplomatic partnership, something that they will build on during their time with the Fremen in the years to come. It's, therefore, a shame that this scene didn't make it into Denis Villeneuve's Dune adaptation. Partway through the dinner, an agent of Hawat steals the Duke away for some pressing security matter, and Paul takes his place at the head of the table. Almost immediately, a banker brazenly insults Paul, though he responds with an effective counter that causes the banker to push his chair back from the table.

Kynes defuses the tense atmosphere by exerting an unexpected level of power over the banker, which arouses Jessica's suspicion. She becomes confused by the source of Kynes' influence since it can't just be his administrative position as Judge. This banquet brilliantly foreshadows Kynes as a mysterious and dangerous figure, so if it were included in Villeneuve's version of Dune, it could have added to the depth of Kynes' film counterpart. Ultimately, the scene provides an immense amount of worldbuilding for Dune by laying out the tentacles of bureaucracy. Given that Villeneuve divided the book in half for his adaptation, it is interesting that despite Herbert's desire to have this moment produced on screen that there was still presumably no room for it in the film.

Considering that Part One was almost entirely expository, it seems like this would have been a singular opportunity to display the power brokers vying for their portion and the loyalty that the Duke inspired in his men. Having this scene in the movie could have also added depth to the paradigms that both the Harkonnens and Atreides have influenced with their colonial apparatus, for good and ill. There is a chance that it could be shot and used as a flashback in Dune: Part Two, finally bringing the scene to life. It'd be a natural segue into introducing characters such as Irulan, especially since this was a focus on the sole adaptation of the scene in the TV miniseries version of Dune. Even if it remains absent from the remake continuity, it won't be the only scene to be excised.

There Were Plenty of Other Elements Missing from Dune 2021

Josh Brolin, Oscar Isaac, Timothee Chamalet, and Rebecca Ferguson in Dune (2021)
Related
10 Best Movies Starring The Dune: Part 2 Cast
Dune: Part 2 is a sci-fi blockbuster with a stacked ensemble cast, and fans of these actors have plenty of other films to check out.

Trivia

  • Frank Herbert wrote six Dune novels in all, ending with Chapterhouse: Dune in 1985. His son, Brian Herbert, and writer Kevin J. Anderson have continued the series in the decades since.

The Conservatory

As shown in the unadapted dinner sequence, Lady Jessica had an even more important role in the original Dune novel. Another way this manifested was a scene in which she finds a conservatory within her new family home. This was important because it showcased a water source on the dry, arid Arrakis. The scene was missing entirely, with Paul and House Atreides never really shown exploring their new home.

The scene in the novel also had Lady Jessica discovering a note about a potential traitor. This planted the seeds of a conspiracy, making her distrustful as to who was supposedly going to betray her master, Leto. Of course, these elements segued into what would have been present in the dinner sequence, so it makes sense that they were removed.

Gurney's Musical Talent

Gurney Halleck acts as the weapons master for the House Atreides, even angrily testing Paul to a duel early in the movie. Played by Josh Brolin, he had a gruff and rather stony characterization throughout the movie. While this is accurate to the source material, it's missing key elements that made Gurney more well-rounded.

Gurney was known for combining the minstrel with the warrior, being just as artistic, astute, and entertaining as he was battle-ready. He frequently performed music in the book, namely in the dinner/banquet scene. There were actually scenes shot and music pieces produced for footage where Brolin's Gurney emulated these multifaceted traits, but they were sadly not featured in the final cut.

Related
Dune: Part Two Makes a Major Change to a Main Character
Dune: Part Two sees Paul Atreides rise to power among the Fremen of Arrakis, but one character's reaction to Muad'Dib differs greatly from the novel.

Characters Cut for the Sequel

The narrator for the Dune novel and even the David Lynch movie is Princess Irulan. Though her role is initially small throughout the first novel, it increases as in the series' sequels such as Dune: Messiah. This is namely due to her becoming the wife of Paul Atreides, though theirs is a purely political marriage that doesn't result in children.

Irulan is not seen or heard from at all in Villeneuve's first Dune, though she's set to be played by Florence Pugh in Dune: Part Two. Similarly, Feyd-Rautha Harkonnen was not among his family's ranks during any scenes in Dune: Part One. This differed from the book and the original movie (where the character was notably played by Sting), as he was always present with either his uncle Vladimir Harkonnen and his cousin Rabban. The character is also set to show up in the sequel, played by Austin Butler.

Dune: Messiah Needs To Include More Political Intrigue

Politics Play a Major Role in the Dune Story, Meaning Villeneuve Needs to Ramp Up the Intrigue

Related
Dune: Part Two's Biggest Plot Holes and Burning Questions
Denis Villeneuve's Dune: Part Two continues Paul Atreides' tale of rebellion and revenge against House Harkonnen, but not all threads are neatly tied.

Trivia

  • Dune: Messiah was released in 1969. The sequel was written in part to demonstrate Paul Atreides' darker side after some readers misidentified him as a hero in the original book.

Denis Villeneuve wants to make Dune: Messiah and, given the popularity and financial success of the first two films, it seems very likely that he'll get to. As well-received as Dune and its 2024 sequel have been, sequels could benefit from more political intrigue. Dune: Part Two began introducing more political figures, including Emperor Shaddam IV and his daughter, Princess Irulan. The film also made reference to the other Great Houses of the galaxy, hinting at a wider political milieu in the franchise. However, the film only briefly touches on these storylines.

Dune: Messiah can deal with how the other Great Houses deal with Paul Atreides's rise to power--and how Paul intends to maintain power now that he has defeated the Harkonnens. Political intrigue, when done right, can be a powerful storytelling device, expanding the lore of the franchise and heightening the stakes for its main character. Important character moments like the cut banquet sequence in Dune would be most welcome in such a film, showing just how politically savvy the Atreides are.

Dune Part 2 is currently in theaters.

Dune 2021 Movie Poster featuring Josh Brolin, Oscar Isaac, Timothy Chalanet
Dune
PG-13
Action
Adventure
Drama

Original title: Dune: Part One.
A noble family becomes embroiled in a war for control over the galaxy's most valuable asset while its heir becomes troubled by visions of a dark future.

Release Date
September 3, 2021
Director
Denis Villeneuve
Cast
Oscar Isaac , Rebecca Ferguson , Timothee Chalamet , Dave Bautista , Zendaya , Josh Brolin , Jason Momoa
Runtime
2 hours 35 minutes