Vertigo has produced a number of one-shots that harken back to various DC anthologies of yesterday, dusting off titles like Strange Adventures and The Unexpected and giving them a modern Vertigo flavor. The latest is Mystery in Space, which includes sci-fi stories by creators like Mike Allred, Kyle Baker, Ann Nocenti, Ming Doyle, Andy Diggle, Michael Wm. Kaluta, Ramón F. Bachs and many more.
Like most anthologies, there are hits and misses. Here are some overall opinions on the collection; if you're curious what people thought about each individual story, I recommend heading over to the reviews by Multiversity Comics, Martin Gray or Comics Bulletin.
Martin Gray, Too Dangerous for a Girl: "Mystery in Space #1 has a beautiful cover by Ryan Sook, evoking celestial wonder. As for the rest of the book, the only wonder is that someone thought it was fit to publish as a $7.99, 80pp giant. For while the revived Silver Age one-off hosts a few decently written and drawn stories with an intriguing idea or two, much of the material proved a slog to get through."
Jason Clyna, Broken Frontier: "Vertigo’s new Mystery in Space anthology is so much more than a loose collection of stories. Several of these unconnected tales boggle the mind, break the laws of physics, and challenge humanity’s concept of reality. Over the course of more than 70 consistently gorgeous pages, Duane Swierczynski, Michael Allred, Andy Diggle, and many more tell their own short stories that will satisfy fans of both science fiction and quality storytelling."
Danny Djeljosevic, Comics Bulletin: "The various editors all contributing to this anthology is akin to a record with a different producer on each track -- individual songs might be okay, but as an album it doesn't hold together. While on one hand it's cool that apparently everyone in the Vertigo office jammed together to put out Mystery in Space, as a collection of nine stories all under the same cover, there's a distinct lack of unity."
Joshua Yehl, IGN: "With each story only being several pages long, the creative teams are tasked with establishing their sci-fi world and then telling a complete story in a short span, and some are more successful than others. A few of the writers get too caught up in their philosophical arguments, reality-altering aliens, and space-witches, leaving the best story being the one about a group of space-garbage-men in a three-way relationship. Robert Rodi’s writing is sharp and humorous, while Sebastian Fiumara’s artwork clearly tells the story with excellent character designs and creative sci-fi machinery. Aliens might be weird, but human behavior always seems to reign supreme on the weird-stuff-o-meter."
Colin Smith, Too Busy Thinking About My Comics: "It’s tough working out who Mystery In Space was actually intended for. Comics readers are unlikely to take to such unengaging and expensive fare, while the chances of attracting science-fiction fans from other mediums is seriously limited by the functional-at-best art and the mediocre scripts. The short story is an incredibly demanding form, and anything other than excellence will soon get found out. A cluster of so-so tales will work as well as a gaggle of also-ran album-tracks trading under the title of a 'greatest hits' collection, context being a promise, etc, etc. Was it too many editors that spoiled the broth, or have folks just forgotten the art of the fiercely compelling short story?"