MARVEL STRANGE TALES III: A PROPOSAL
Yes, it's cute to see "indie" artists take a shot at Marvel's characters every once in a while. Marvel has done it twice now, but I think they should go in a different direction for "Strange Tales 3." Rather than get indie comic creators, I think they should hire children's story book artists to handle the art chores.
Yes, this book should be done in illustrated storybook style. In fact, it should be printed directly onto board books. Skip the pamphlets and the standard comic size formatting. Go straight for the children's book market with this. They're sturdier, will last on shelves longer, will hold up to the punishment a kid might throw at it, and the relatively high price per page count fits in wonderfully with the comics industry's business model right now. (Really: a 16 page board book might run $7 and there's only one illustration per page or two, often.)
Even better: Let it be one long, continuous story, in which each book is a self-contained complete tale. Don't take six issues to tell one story. Think about a book series, like "Harry Potter," where each book is a big story unto itself, but there's an on-going saga at work if you read all of them. Don't think about the latest and greatest mega-crossover where, six issues later, you still think you missed half the story.
Here's a quick sampling of artists who have books on my daughter's bookshelves who would do idiosyncratic and potentially cool Marvel stories:
Sandra Boynton: By far, my favorite children's author, even though she's tended to go off on a lot of tangents lately with writing songs that happen to be story books. "But Not the Hippopotamus" is the best of the best, and that's saying a lot for an author whose oeuvre includes "Moo Baa La La La" and "Barnyard Dance!"
Just picture a Spider-Man story from her with The Rhino and Doctor Octopus and Howard the Duck. I throw Howard in there because I like Boynton's ducks, what can I say? And I'd pay good money (OK, maybe $7) just to see her version of Wolverine. He'd be awfully cute.
Kady MacDonald Denton: This book, "A Visitor for Bear," is larger than my scanner, so please pardon the top and bottom edges getting cut off. I discovered it last year and bought it strictly for the art. Even now, it's a little wordy for my daughter, but I can paraphrase as we breeze through the pages. Denton has a great painted style combined with strong cartooning that makes her style a Must Have for "Strange Tales 3."
"A Visitor for Bear" is a funny story about a bear who wants to be left alone, but who finally discovers that having a friend maybe isn't such a bad idea, after all. It's the story of The Hulk, really, who just wants everyone to leave him alone, but who befriends a tenacious little guy (Mouse Rick Jones?) for a cup of tea. I know what story I want to see her draw now...
Laura Numeroff and Felicia Bond: Bond is the artist here, but the style of this series of "Mouse" books requires both creators to properly pull it off. Let the two craft a circular story for the Marvel character of their choice. It could be fun.
Plus, these books are wildly commercially successful, so including these two creators would be a nice marketing coup.
Tim Raglin: Just take a look at the images. Detailed, beautiful, jam-packed. I'm in awe of his art in this book, "The Birthday ABC," which is a series of 25 animal drawings (couldn't find an "X" animal). Each one goes to great lengths to show the creature in a specific time period and location.
I just recently discovered this book (originally published in 1995, it looks like), and am thrilled to see that he's done a lot more than just this one. I have a lot of this art style to look forward to. I just hope my daughter likes it. I need to start with "The Curse of Catunkhamun." That cover is awesome.
And if that doesn't sell you on his stuff, check out his football illustration, "Bears vs. Beavers."
Caroline Jayne Church: There are a billion different "I Love You" style books on the market today. I think we have three or four of them sitting on the shelf in the room next to where I'm writing this. "I Love You Through and Through" is one of my favorites. It's written for the very young, with few words per page and large images, but the use of texture on the pages is what impresses me. Church's style is "ultra-cartoony." But when you look close enough, you'll see that her pages have flecks of color spread across them. I'm not sure what the technique is at all, but it works to make relatively simple (and terribly cute) drawings into something with an extra level to them.
Alyssa Satin Capucilli: She's the artist on a "Biscuit" book or two that we have here at Pipeline World Headquarters. From what I understand, a series of artists have handled the series, and they're all based on the style of the original illustrator, Pat Schories. I'll stick with Capucilli's overly cute and furry animals for this project, since it's what I know. I think she'd draw a great "Pet Avengers" story, don't you? It could be everything that many of the nay-sayers assumed a book like "Pet Avengers" would be: Cute, cuddly, soft, warm and sentimental to a fault. Bring it on.