TOP

You Decide ’09 – Week 3 Results!

by  in Comic News Comment

Each day in October I’ll give you folks a poll question. Each poll will last four days. The results will be posted every Tuesday leading up to (and ending with) Election Day on the first Tuesday in November. Here is the master list of all questions asked so far!

And here are the third week’s worth of poll results!

Enjoy!

I’ll be giving the rounded percentage numbers (like 37% instead of 36.8%), except to break a tie! Because of rounded numbers, some percentages may seem to add up to more than 100%.
____________________________________________________________

Out of 1,291 replies to the question:

What Was the Best America’s Best Comics Title?

You decided:

35% Top 10

33% League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

18% Promethea

12% Tom Strong

2% Tomorrow Stories
____________________________________________________________

Out of 2,280 replies to the question (2,280? Wow!):

Who is your favorite Robin?

You decided:

46% Tim Drake

31% Dick Grayson

12% Damian Wayne

6% Carrie Kelly

2.41% Stephanie Brown

1.84% Jason Todd
____________________________________________________________

Out of 1,249 replies to the question:

Which of these Garth Ennis works is the best?

You decided:

56% Preacher

23% Punisher

21% Hitman
____________________________________________________________

Out of 1,884 replies to the question:

Which is your favorite Hank Pym identity?

You decided:

34% Yellowjacket

21% Doctor Pym

18% Ant-Man

13% Giant-Man

7.32% Wasp

6.53% Goliath
____________________________________________________________

Out of 1,225 replies to the question:

Who was your favorite member of the Suicide Squad?

You decided:

43% Deadshot

17% Amanda Waller

10% Captain Boomerang

3.84% Bronze Tiger

3.51% Oracle

3.27% Shade, the Changing Man

3.1% Rick Flag

2.69% Captain Cold

2.12% Nightshade

1.96% Poison Ivy

1.63% Count Vertigo

1.31% Nemesis

1.22% Vixen

1.14% Enchantress

0.98% Punch and Jewelee

0.57% Atom

0.57% Black Orchid

0.49% Duchess

0.49% Doctor Light

0.41% Ravan

0.24% Major Victory

0.08% Outlaw

0.08% Javelin

0.08% Thinker

0.0% Karin Grace
____________________________________________________________

Out of 1,334 replies to the question:

Who was your favorite penciler from Chris Claremont’s original X-Men run?

You decided:

40% John Byrne

14% Jim Lee

12% Paul Smith

8% Dave Cockrum

5.43% John Romita, Jr.

4.99% Marc Silvestri

4% Alan Davis

3% Art Adams

1.86% Barry Windsor-Smith

1.71% Bill Sienkiewicz

1.26% George Perez

0.74% Andy Kubert

0.6% Rick Leonardi

0.6% Walt Simonson

0.3% Bret Blevins

0.3% Whilce Portacio

0.22% Brent Anderson

0.22% Rob Liefeld

0.07% Larry Stroman

0.07% Klaus Janson

0.07% Kieron Dwyer

0.07% Kerry Gammill

0.07% Bob McLeod

0.07% Michael Golden

0.07% Steve Leialoha

0.0.% Tony Dezuniga

0.0.% June Brigman

0.0.% Bill Jaaska

0.0.% Mike Collins

0.0.% Jim Sherman

0.0.% Jackson Guice
____________________________________________________________

Out of 1,244 replies to the question:

Who is your favorite Captain America writer?

You decided:

49% Ed Brubaker

16% Mark Gruenwald

10% Mark Waid

7% Steve Englehart

6% Roger Stern

3.27% J.M. DeMatteis

2.87% Jack Kirby

2.31% Jim Steranko

1.67% Stan Lee

1% Joe Simon and Jack Kirby

0.48% Robert Morales

0.16% Steve Gerber

0.16% Roger McKenzie

0.0% Gary Friedrich

0.0% Dan Jurgens
____________________________________________________________

Check back next Tuesday for the latest results, and check back every day to vote on the You Decide ’09 question of the day!